|1st||Ubaldo Jimenez||Chris Iannetta||Todd Helton||DJ LeMahieu||Nolan Arenado||Troy Tulowitzki||Matt Holliday||Dexter Fowler||Larry Walker|
|2nd||Aaron Cook||Jeff Reed||Andres Galarraga||Eric Young||Vinny Castilla||Walt Weiss||Carlos Gonzalez||Juan Pierre||Brad Hawpe|
|3rd||Jhoulys Chacin||Wilin Rosario||Ben Paulsen||Clint Barmes||Garrett Atkins||Neifi Perez||Corey Dickerson||Ellis Burks||Dante Bichette|
First base and left field were hard to find a 3rd Teamer for. For first base, Mr. Rockie, Todd Helton, held it down for over half of the franchise's existence, and Andres Galarraga had a solid five-year run too. Justin Morneau also had a good season at the position, but with the three-year minimum required for this list, he couldn't make it. Ben Paulsen, enjoy your small claim to fame! Left field was hard just because it's one of those positions where several players tend to get tried, and I chose Dickerson because he seemed as good a choice as any.
Third base has been a surprisingly strong position for Colorado in its short history. Jeff Cirillo would've made the list had he played one more season with the Rockies, but there's no shame in having Garrett Atkins show up here.
Pitcher and catcher were surprisingly weak spots. Perhaps pitcher isn't too surprising, since the mile-high air is famously tough on hurlers, but you'd think there would've been at least one catcher better than Chris Iannetta. Nope. I suppose a quarter-century without ever having a great catcher isn't unheard-of in baseball, though.
DJ LeMahieu must be one of the most underrated players in the game. Who knew he was already the greatest Rockie second baseman of all time? Seriously, fans. Appreciate this guy.