Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Talkin' Baseball With edhardiman!

Last offseason on my now-defunct FoxSports blog I did a series of interviews with other bloggers about their baseball fandom. It ended up being a pretty popular series, and I don't know if I myself ever had more fun blogging than when I put those posts together. Now that the offseason is unfortunately here again we fans of the world's greatest sport need something to keep the flame burning. I thought I'd share those interviews over here so that they don't get relegated to obscurity. You probably won't know these bloggers, but if you're like me, you love hearing baseball fans talk about their memories of the game. Since these are from last offseason, a few of the questions and answers are a little dated, but it shouldn't make them any less enjoyable.

This is the second one I did, with Ed Hardiman, a Phillies fan. Ed took some crap for his comments on Sabermetrics, but there's a lot here to like even if you disagree with him in that department.


1. Where did it all begin? When and how did you become a baseball fan?

Maz hits the walk off HR to beat the Yankees in the World Serious. I remember hearing the call on the radio the next day.

2. Of all the baseball games you've attended, which one is your favorite?

Had to be the 1st home game of the infamous '64 collapse when the Phillies got beat 1-0. Art Mahaffey's glacial delivery allowed a guy to steal home.

3. Which do you like best: Connie Mack Stadium, Veterans Stadium or Citizen's Bank Park?

Connie Mack, the Vet, then CBP...that's my order of preference...

4. What did you honestly think the Phillies' chances of winning the World Series were going into the 2008 season?

Are you kidding? We eliminate the Phillies from postseason contention no later than November the previous season over at the BIT, my favorite baseball forum...

5. Who were the best and worst Phillie managers you ever saw?

Best ever is tough. Have to go Dallas Green but hate him for stealing Ryne Sandberg. Worst ever is a tie between Frank Lucchesi & Nick Leyva.

6. I'll name some names and you tell me what comes to mind. It can be a memory, a thought, or whatever you want.

Johnny Briggs= Another "never lived up to expectations" guy from the 60's.

Don Money= 1 good season, 3 so-so ones. His career came after the Phillies with Milwaukee...they traded Bunning to get him and then traded him for Lonborg and the wrong Brett, Ken.

Wayne Twitchell= Twitch? Did you dig these guys up from the Phillies Pet Sematary? Another bust on the mound.

Larry Christenson= Great pitcher, always hurt.

Del Unser= Had his career Last Hurrah seasons in '79 & '80 with the Phillies, smell the Del.

Jeff Stone= Another disappointing 80's guy. 2 and half good seasons then throws it in reverse. I think he once swatted a couple of potatoes in one game and never came close to the fence ever again. I would have preferred Steve Jeltz or Juan Samuel as a question...j/k.

Pat Combs= The Phillies flat out overcoached him and yoyo'd him between AAA & the club out of a career. A real shame, 'cause the kid pre-headcase was pretty decent. They Steve Blassed him. I haven't trusted a 2nd half of the season wonder ever since Combs. He's the poster boy for why the Phillies farm system is where pitchers go to die.

Jim Eisenreich= Awesome, gutsy player. The '93 team was full of them. True grit.

Kevin Jordan= Forget him, my favorite Phillies Jordan was Ricky Jordan, the 1st sacker who hit two different people in the stands with bats one game I was at 'cause his hands were swollen and the dope manager, I think it was Leyva, made him play. His hands looked like two cantaloupes...one of the bats augered in on a lady's head like a hellfire missile shaking hands with an Iraqi tank...

7. Do you think Dick Allen belongs in the Hall of Fame?

Absolutely. It's a crime he isn't in, but you know baseball always hated Richie...he used to make a question mark with his bat while waiting for a pitch. I think every kid in lil league copied it. He owned a house up where I lived near Philly and you would see him drinking in tiny bars minding his own business. A real gentleman.

8. If Mitch Williams escapes the 9th inning of Game 6 unscathed, does Danny Jackson beat Pat Hentgen in Game 7?

The blame rests on Fregosi. Friggles had an open base for Carter, Mitch pitched out of a gazillion bases-loaded jams, then to compound the error, Friggles has him pitch out of the stretch, which he never did. It knocked 15 MPH off his fastball. As to your question, I think Jackson had the lightning in the bottle that season and the Phillies had enough sticks to win, but as the old saying goes, if wishes were pigs there'd be no bacon. OK I made that up, but it's pretty good. The only guy I ever met who could recall every pitch in that game is The Dan. He'll tell you Friggles not giving Hollins the take sign with two men on and two out when Stewart walked two straight on eight wild pitches really cost the Phillies the game, because Hollins swung at a ball and weakly flied out.

9. You gained some notoriety on the internet last year thanks to your "Slobbermetrics" article. In all seriousness though, what do you really think of Sabermetrics?

As a viable interpretation of the past it's OK, as a predictor of the future, not so hot. Moneyball hasn't changed baseball. Influenced it perhaps and improved Boston, but what has it done for the A's? I think Charlie Lau's contact hitting sytem has had a far greater impact than Sabermetrics. It's like believing in fortune tellers. If you exclude the failures it looks great, when you factor them in it resembles flipping a coin. Why wouldn't a Kansas City just hire the brightest SABR guy if it was so infallible? I'm OK with people who live and die by it, but don't try to cram it down our throats or claim it's the last word in understanding baseball. Even Bill James refutes that notion. It's math that can't pass any rigorous testing. If the player doesn't conform he's underperformed? How about the math underperfomed and individual humans can't be expressed mathematically? What about the 2008 Mets? Sabermetrically, that team was better than the Phillies. Just grade out the pitching staffs and the Phillies shouldn't have been a speck in the Mets' rearview mirror. The Cubbies should've beaten the Dodgers SABR-metrically, what happened? That's why I take it with a grain of salt.

10. What changes would you make if you were in charge of Major League Baseball?

Come clean or get bounced out would be my PED policy. It cons the fans first and foremost out of what they pay to see: the best, not the most chemically enhanced. I'd raise the pitching mounds so the turnstile pitching staffs would become a loathed memory. Balance makes the sport great. This artificial dinger ball from the Selig era is like pork rinds. How many can you eat before harking? I'd make umps and players get through games in under two hours. Enough with the triple switches, mound conferences and hitters adjusting their jocks every pitch. Finally, I'd mandate a section of every stadium priced at $5 a seat. If fans can build a stadium they sure as hell should be able to afford to attend a game.

11. What do you expect from the Phillies in 2009?

We've eliminated them already at the BIT. Promoting Rube Amaro is a disaster, like one of those movies from the 70's where Steve McQueen is a fire chief wandering through a towering inferno while the audience wonders what the hell he's doing in such a cheesy, crummy flick.

12. To sum things up, tell us what the game of baseball means to you.

Baseball speaks to me from every era. From players like Pickles Dillhoefer right up to Ryan Howard, it exemplifies what I like to call American Splendor...


For more of Ed's entertaining scribble, you can check out his blog.

Monday, November 9, 2009

Talkin' Baseball With bosox61!

Last offseason on my now-defunct FoxSports blog I did a series of interviews with other bloggers about their baseball fandom. It ended up being a pretty popular series, and I don't know if I myself ever had more fun blogging than when I put those posts together. Now that the offseason is unfortunately here again we fans of the world's greatest sport need something to keep the flame burning. I thought I'd share those interviews over here so that they don't get relegated to obscurity. You probably won't know these bloggers, but if you're like me, you love hearing baseball fans talk about their memories of the game. Since these are from last offseason, a few of the questions and answers are a little dated, but it shouldn't make them any less enjoyable.

This is the first one I did, with bosox61 (Paul), a fan of both the Red Sox and the Rays.



1. Let's start at the beginning: When and how did you become a baseball fan?

I was about nine or ten years old when my love affair with baseball began, and as I look back at my past, I tend to think that baseball served to fill a void in my life that desperately needed filling. My Dad passed away in 1953 causing a lot of changes in my home. My older brothers had both gone off to the service and my Mom had to go to work in order to support the family. I found myself alone a lot of the time and somehow became infatuated with playing baseball. At first it was on the streets by my house and as I grew a little older it moved to a playground about a quarter of a mile away.

In 1955 my Mom sent me to stay with my sister and her husband in Long Island, New York for the summer. My brother in law was an ardent New York Giants baseball fan and took me to the Polo Grounds many times to see his team play. He also taught me how to properly read the sports page of the local newspapers and I became enamored with statistics. He also taught me how to be a proper Yankee hater. I think I had that one down pat before I ever developed my life long love affair with the Red Sox.

As the summer of 1956 approached, I wasn't really too keen on going to New York mainly because of the Red Sox. I had become a fan and will never forget the lineup the Sox fielded that year. It was beyond my comprehension to even think that there was a better outfield than Ted Williams, Jimmy Piersall and Jackie Jensen. Yogi couldn't possibly be as good as Sammy White. Don Buddin was going to be the All-Star shortstop for many years to come.

It was in 1956 that I first started to question front office moves. The Sox signed Mickey Vernon to play first base (a move that made no sense to me). They already had a first baseman named Norm Zauchin who hit 27 homers the year before with over 90 RBIs and I thought he was great.

The Sox had a pretty good year in '56 and another in '57, although they finished down in the standings both years. But then the slide came. They managed to have 9 straight losing seasons after that and although I still loved the Red Sox, I accepted that they just plain sucked.

Well that's it. I was about 8 years old when I learned to love playing the game. However, it wasn't for another year or so before I became a fan of the game played by others.

2. Of all the baseball games you've attended, which one is your favorite?

I actually wrote about this last April. I'll just repeat the story here.

I was fourteen years old and probably had been to 50 or 60 games up to that point in my life. I lived and died baseball back then (as most of us did and I still do) and when someone came up with the idea of going to see the Red Sox play a twilight doubleheader against the Tigers, I was all for it. It was a Tuesday or Wednesday night right before the Labor Day weekend and school was starting right after that. We went to four different schools back then and knew that we weren't going to be seeing each other very much now that the summer was almost all over so the game was a great idea.

The Red Sox were about 20 games back in the standings but that didn't matter. We met at Uphams Corner in Dorchester and caught a bus to Andrew Station. From there we caught the subway to the Park Street station where we transferred to a trolley to Kenmore square which is less than a 10-minute walk to Fenway. Everyone else on the street was going to the ballgame and we got caught up in the excitement long before we bought our tickets. It cost a buck to get bleacher seats in right field. The first game was to start at 4:00pm and we got there early enough to get seats next to the visiting bullpen.

Billy Monbouquette was pitching for the Sox in the first game against the Tigers' Frank Lary. They both pitched pretty well but neither of them was involved in the decision. At the end of the 9th inning they were in a four to four tie and nobody but the Sox second baseman (Pete Runnels) seemed to want to win the game. Finally, after 4 hours and in the bottom of the 15th inning, Runnels hit a drive into the triangle next to the Red Sox bullpen and scored Frank Malzone from first base. It was Pete Runnels' 6th hit of the game and the place went crazy.

It took close to an hour to get the second game started. This was going to be another good one. Earl Wilson was pitching against Jim Bunning. The sore spot was that Ted Williams was not going to play in the second game. In the top of the 9th inning Rocky Colavito hit a monster shot over the left field wall to tie the game and put us into extra inning again. Thank goodness the Sox scored in the bottom of the 10th on a throwing error by the Tigers' shortstop and ended up winning both ends of the double header. Pete Runnels had three more hits in the second game to raise his total to 9 hits for the day. I think that was some kind of a record at the time.

The coolest thing about the game was not actually the game. We spent over 9 hours next to the visitors' bullpen and got to know some of the Tiger pitchers. Hank Aguirre and Paul Foytack were the two I remember most and they were terrific. Rocky Colavito was the Tiger right fielder and he interacted with us during both games. I sort of became a Tiger fan after that and grasped at the opportunity to visit Tiger Stadium in 1972 when I was in Windsor on business.

Now we ran into problems. Public transportation stopped at 1:00pm back then and the lateness of the game was only going to change the number of subway cars, not the time schedule. We ran like heck to the Kenmore Square station and caught a trolley to Park Street. There we managed to get the last subway back to Andrew Station but only found that the last bus home had already left. We had I'm guessing about a five mile walk ahead of us. It was after 1:00am and we were all in trouble as we were all 14 or 15 years old and it was not acceptable to be out that late. There were no cell phones and we couldn't find a pay phone during the walk to alert our families of our whereabouts. About half way home a Boston Police Department cruiser stopped us and the policeman inquired as to why we were out that late. Upon hearing our explanation and seeing a ticket stub he graciously drove us home.

However, this caused us more problems. All our parents were still awake waiting for us. They saw the police car drop us off one by one.. My Mom was at the top of the front steps when I arrived. She only asked me if I was all right and then getting a positive answer told me to go to bed. The next morning was a different story. Back then it was very embarrassing for parents to have their children brought home in a police car. None of us got through that unscathed. When I asked my Mom recently if she remembered the incident she only remembered the night that the police brought me home. It's funny how one of the best baseball nights of my life caused me so much trouble.

I think my second favorite game was the one that took place at the Trop on September 11th, 2002. My wife and I wanted to do something "patriotic" on the anniversary of 9/11 and going to a baseball game seemed to be the right thing to do. The Red Sox were in town and Pedro was pitching. The Sox won easily but we were both moved by the experience. The Devil Rays had a ceremony that would have moved the most stoic of people.

3. You've said that you had a feeling about the 2008 Rays in Spring Training. Did you have a similar feeling about the 2004 Red Sox?

Absolutely not! When that season started the Sox had a brand new 37-year-old pitcher in Curt Schilling. Did he have anything left? Could Wakefield give you 30 decent starts? What the hell was a Bronson Arroyo? It was Lowe and Pedro and cross your fingers. Could Keith Foulke match what he did in Oakland and Chicago? Did Timlin and Embree have 70+ appearances in them? If they didn't, it was going to be a long season.

You also have to remember that the Sox began the year with Pokey Reese as their shortstop and Mark Bellhorn in his first season with the team at second. Gabe Kapler began the season in right field because Trot Nixon was broken for much of the season. And don't forget, Nomar was broken for most of the year before he was traded.

Taking this all into account and realizing that the Sox were almost as old as the Yankees, it didn't bode well for the 2004 season from my point of view.

When the Sox were down 2 games in the ALCS to the Yankees and were losing in game 3, my wife announced that when the Red Sox won the World Series the whole family was going to get Red Sox tattoos and she was paying for them. Just to humor her, I agreed to it. It was the same for my daughters. I was just shy of my 60th birthday when I blessed my body with a red B on my left shoulder. The whole family flew into Tampa for the tattoo party in Ybor City.

4. Do you have any memories of the Boston Braves? What was the status of their fans after the franchise left for Milwaukee?

I went to 2 games at Braves Field, but I don't remember either one of them. I did see the Milwaukee Braves play in the Polo Grounds in '55 a couple of times. I knew the names but all I really remember was how high Warren Spahn kicked his right leg in the air.

The Braves didn't have much of a following in Boston that I was aware of. But then again I was just a little kid and by the time I got into the Red Sox, they had been gone for a couple of years.

5. What was your most heartbreaking moment as a baseball fan?

When Tony Conigliaro got beaned in August, 1967. For a while it was just like the Kennedy assassination all over again (as absurd as that sounds).

And of course, Bucky "Fucking" Dent. Nuff said about that!

6. I'll name some names and you tell me what comes to mind. It can be a memory, a thought, or whatever you want:

Ike Delock= (#14) I liked Ike; both in politics and on the Fenway bump. He played his whole career with the Sox. He was a pretty good reliever for the first couple of years I watched him but he became an average starter for some really bad Red Sox teams.

Chuck Schilling= (#2) He came up with Yaz in 1961 and had a real good rookie season at 2nd base. Had high hopes for Schilling but he only lasted a couple of more years.

Dalton Jones= (#3) This guy's career has never made any sense to me. He had the prettiest swing you ever saw. He played all the infield positions in a utility role and was a great pinch hitter. He was one of my favorites but could never hit consistently enough to stay in the lineup.

Rick Miller= (#16; #3) Everyone in Boston loved Rick Miller. He was a good ball player but nobody ever took him serious enough to let him play every day. He had 2 stints with the Sox; playing 3 years with the Angels in between. If memory serves me right, he was married to Carlton Fisk's sister or Fisk was married to his sister. Something like that anyway.

Wade Boggs= (#26) Wade Boggs sucks! I should have many great memories of Boggs but they were all deleted when he signed with the Yankees. I will never forgive that and refuse to acknowledge that he ever played for the Red Sox.

Kevin Romine= (#16) Not a whole lot to remember about this guy. He was a utility outfielder who was probably the 25th man on the roster for most of his career. Played his whole career with the Sox.

Tim Naehring= (#11) This guy was a good ballplayer. He was the starting 3rd baseman for a couple of years in the mid nineties and was a good hitter. John Valentin took his job away and he left the game. Another guy who played his whole career for the Sox.

Aubrey Huff= I never liked Huff when he played for the D-Rays. He was a great hitter and an adequate fielder in a number of positions, but he had this way about him. He had this "strut" that drove me crazy. He was like the villain blond headed kid who was a member of the Cobra Kai in the Karate Kid Movie. Talented, but you had to hate him. This is only my opinion though. I have never heard anyone else express this opinion of him.

Lance Carter= Somebody had to go to the All-Star game in 2003 and since they already had enough outfielders, it wasn't going to be Aubrey Huff. That Game was pretty much Lance Carter's claim to fame. If the D-Rays didn't exist, he probably never would have played at the Major League level.

7. There seems to be a lot of resentment among Red Sox fans toward "pink hats", i.e. fans who jumped on the bandwagon five years ago. What's your opinion on this issue? Do you feel that bandwagoners are cheapening the culture surrounding the Red Sox?

I don't consider it an issue. My sister has never been much of a baseball fan. She probably went to one or two baseball games a year for most of her adult life (this was during the time when you could get tickets at Fenway without taking out a second mortgage). In 2004 she got caught up in the Red Sox pennant drive; probably because her friends did. In '05 and '06, I don't think she even knew where the Sox finished. But low and behold, she got caught up in it again in '07. Should I be critical of my sister because she is a fair-weather Red Sox fan? Hell no! I'm thrilled to have something else to talk about with her that doesn't concern the family.

I personally think that people who engage in these kinds of discussions are morons. And I don't care what team they support or what sport they support. That's all I have to say about that.

8. Not counting any year where the Red Sox won the World Series, what was your favorite season of following baseball?

1967! I had just come back to the World and baseball was the only thing I could concentrate on besides the level of intoxication I needed to achieve just to function. I believe it saved my sanity, although I'm sure a lot of folks would say that wasn't so.

9. Do you think the Rays need a new ballpark, or is Tropicana Field good enough for now?

I think that the Trop is fine as far as a facility is concerned. I like the fact that I don't have to sit in a ballpark at 10:00pm when the temperature is 90 degrees with an 80% humidity level. However I will concede that the stadium is located in probably the worst place it could be as far as fan support goes. So I suppose my answer to the question is yes, they need a new stadium in a more favorable location.

10. What changes would you make if you were in charge of Major League Baseball?

I'd kill interleague play and set up balanced schedules again. I'd kill that ridiculous idea that the All-Star Game should mean something. I would do anything that makes the playing field even. Bud Selig is unfairly criticized in my opinion for not doing the things that so many of us would like to have done. The man is extremely limited in what he can do besides tend the seeds that have already been planted. After Fay Vincent resigned, the owners lopped off a great deal of the powers that the Commissioner once had. As a result, the commissioners since then have no power to build anything without the owners and the Players Association giving their blessing. All they can do today is throw a new coat of paint on it every now and then to bring in more revenue.

11. Do you see both the Rays and the Red Sox making the Playoffs again next year?

At this point I can't see why not. Ask me again in February when all these teams have retooled. You know that the Yankees are going to do something and probably a lot of things. The Orioles were not that bad last season and Cito Gaston made the Jays respectable; it was just too late to make a difference.

The Twins are for real and I think that the Indians and the Tigers were aberrations last season. The Royals may be next seasons Rays. No offense to you, but I don't see the White Sox being as good next year. And don't ever turn your back on Billy Beane.

As far as the Rays go, I don't know. When you have 14 .260 hitters and 11 pretty good pitchers, chemistry and attitude have an awful lot to do with a team's success. You never know what the successful 2008 season will do to that chemistry and attitude in 2009. I think this off-season will really determine if Andrew Friedman is the genius that he is credited with being.

The Red Sox will be there in '09. If they do nothing this winter they will be there and I don't think anybody expects them to do nothing.

12. To sum things up, tell us briefly what the game of baseball means to you.

I love the game of baseball. I think that baseball is the purest of all sports. It is a microcosm of the real world in many respects. The first pitch starts a game as birth starts life. Managers and coaches plan for that first pitch as parents plan for their baby's arrival. The last out symbolizes death. When that out has been made we all can evaluate the success or the failure of that which has past.

In the process, baseball has rules to play by as we have rules to live by and when we don't, there are authorities there to judge and sentence us. In baseball, as in life, there are mentors and teachers and supporters and antagonists. There is no time limit in baseball. A game can be short or it can be long, just as our lives can be short or long.

There are great teams and there are stars. There are also those whose names that we never learn but without who, we could never be successful. There are rewards for great accomplishments and then there are those who win the lottery. There are those who are taken for granted and those who are valued too highly.

In the end, a valued effort may not bring forth outstanding results but the effort can be and is often appreciated.


Still great after almost a year. It looks like he was right about the Red Sox' playoff chances too. You can read more of Paul's fine work here.

Thursday, November 5, 2009

Whoop-Dee-Doo...The Yankees Win the World Series

Earlier this year I read Ty Cobb's autobiography My Life in Baseball: The True Record. This book is often overlooked because it's perceived as a whitewashed version of Cobb's life, but I still enjoyed it. Despite Cobb's known faults, I came away from it with a greater admiration for him and what he contributed to baseball. You may know the story behind the book, as they made a movie out of it: Cobb enlisted sportswriter Al Stump to help him put his words to paper in his later years, and the final product was published shortly after Cobb's death in 1961.

Several chapters of the book consist of Cobb's advice for ballplayers, as well as his thoughts about the state of the game at the time of writing. One thing that's stuck with me is Cobb's disdain for the home run ball. He argued that baseball was meant to be played within the confines of the field, and that home runs hit into the seats violated that ideal. He also said that the sit-back-and-wait-for-a-homer game (which was common in the 1950's) made baseball boring, and that it was the main reason football was threatening to overtake baseball as the most popular sport. While it's easy to dismiss Cobb's words as those of a crotchety old man who thinks everything was better in his day, he may have had a point worth considering.

Baseball was more intense in the deadball era. Teams usually relied on singles, bunts and stolen bases to score runs. The lower the run-scoring environment the more valuable each tally was. You weren't going to wait for your big boppers to park one. You knew that scoring was most likely going to be a process. Most of the advice Cobb dispensed was about outsmarting the opposition in various situations. Players back then had to use their heads to get any advantage they could, whether it be physical or psychological. It was a battle of brains as much as brawn.

That brings us to this year's Yankees. As you probably know, last night they won the 2009 World Series. I guess all fans of good baseball should be rejoicing. After all, these are the Yankees we're talking about. Winning the World Series is part of their fabric, since no other franchise has the commitment to excellence that they do. You'd be hard-pressed to find a collection of players equal in quality. And yet...their achievement seems empty.

It goes without saying that the richer teams have an advantage over the poorer ones. We could reasonably expect the richest clubs to beat out the others every year, but as the saying goes, that's why they play the games. In the almost-decade we went without the Yankees winning the Series we saw several examples of brainpower beating out financial power. Heck, just last year we had the Rays. They built a pennant-winner through solid draft choices, smart trades and shrewd signings. I loved watching their run to the World Series. It reminded us that every team has a chance if they use their heads and play their cards right, and that sometimes the "little guy" wins. It's the type of story that makes me proud to be a baseball fan. Even though the Rays didn't win the World Series, they had a season to be proud of, as it was the culmination of a well-thought-out process.

When C.C. Sabathia, Mark Teixeira and A.J. Burnett hit the market it was pretty much a foregone conclusion that they'd be snatched up by big-money teams, and the Yankees outdid themselves by landing every single one of them. I know, I know. If they have the cash you can't blame them for using it, right? What did the Yankees prove by winning this World Series though? That they can outspend everyone else? Shoot, we already knew that. It takes no special talent to spend money, and it's not unreasonable to think that most teams in baseball could've done the same thing with the same resources.

In sports, we tend to view the season as a sort of narrative. We look for storylines because it enhances our experience. Can this guy finally win a championship? Can this guy prove he isn't washed up? Can this team win its first title in however-many seasons? Like any story, I want a happy ending. I want to believe that the good guys ultimately win and justice prevails. Watching the Yankees win the World Series is kind of like watching Biff Tannen break George McFly's arm and have his way with Lorraine, thus erasing Marty from existence (OK, no more cheesy pop culture references, even if they are from my favorite movie of all time).

Don't get me wrong, I'm not complaining about the Yankees' title being unfair (it is, but that's the nature of the beast). I'm not advocating a salary cap or a return to the reserve clause. I'm just saying that there's nothing about their story that impresses me. Their front office didn't make any ingenious moves I can nod admiringly at. There's no long-suffering fanbase to feel happy for (Nine years? Try being a Cubs fan!). They merely did exactly what a team with such a large advantage would be expected to do: finish on top.

Looking at this Yankee championship, I think I understand how Ty Cobb felt watching the sport in which he took so much pride reduced to a battle of who can outbash whom (at least, in his view). This year's Bronx Bombers proved that monetary brawn and enough brains not to screw things up is a winning formula. No, I'm not making some oversimplified statement that baseball is merely a spending competition. I know there are other clubs whose management could potentially outsmart the Yankees. I also know that the Yankees have an aging core and were lucky enough to get good seasons out of all of them (which is enough to give us Yankee-haters hope for next year). What I am saying is that the significant financial cushion the Yankees have takes the luster off their accomplishment. They may have won it fair and square on the field, but they never gave me any reason to care.

Tuesday, November 3, 2009

PTWSW #20: The 1923 New York Yankees

Manager: Miller Huggins
Record: 98-54
Ballpark: Yankee Stadium
Owner: Jacob Ruppert
GM: Ed Barrow
Coaches: Charley O'Leary

Future Hall of Famers: Lou Gehrig, Waite Hoyt, Herb Pennock, Babe Ruth

Team Leaders, Batting

BA:
Babe Ruth, .393
OBP: Babe Ruth, .545
SLG: Babe Ruth, .764
OPS: Babe Ruth, 1.309
HR: Babe Ruth, 41
RBI: Babe Ruth, 131
SB: Babe Ruth, 17

(You think the offense had a clear-cut leader?)

Team Leaders, Pitching

W: Sam Jones, 21
SO: Joe Bush, Bob Shawkey, 125
ERA: Waite Hoyt, 3.02
IP: Joe Bush, 275.2

Tidbits

Oldest Player:
Ernie Johnson (b. April 29, 1888)

Youngest Player: Lou Gehrig (b. June 19, 1903)

First to Leave Us: Lou Gehrig (d. June 2, 1941). We all know the sad story. The youngest member of the first Yankee World Series champs was the first to pass on, but he sandwiched a Hall of Fame career between his debut and his death.

Last Survivor: Whitey Witt (d. July 14, 1988)

First in Majors: Herb Pennock (debut May 14, 1912)

Last in Majors: Lou Gehrig (final game April 30, 1939)

First to Play For the Franchise: Wally Pipp (April 14, 1915)

Last to Play For the Franchise: Lou Gehrig (April 30, 1939). Wow! The guy playing first base on Opening Day 1915 would be the longest-tenured Yankee by the time the franchise finally won a World Series, and the guy who replaced him a few years later wouldn't miss a game until his career ended, by which point he also would be the longest-tenured Yankee. It's safe to say these guys were set at the initial cushion for a while.

Pre-union Team: The 1919 Red Sox had an astounding nine players who'd later join this team: Joe Bush, Waite Hoyt, Sam Jones, Carl Mays, Mike McNally, Herb Pennock, Babe Ruth, Wally Schang and Everett Scott. Of course, the story behind it is now semi-famous. Red Sox owner Harry Frazee wasn't popular among the other American League owners, and the Yankees and White Sox were the only two teams who agreed to trade with him. When Frazee ran into financial troubles, Yankee GM (and former Red Sox manager) Ed Barrow was only too happy to take his best players off his hands. It should also be noted that this team had a strong Athletics connection. Three of these former Red Sox actually came from Philadelphia by way of Boston (Bush, Pennock and Schang) and Joe Dugan, Bob Shawkey and Whitey Witt all played for Connie Mack in the previous decade.

Reunion Team: The 1926 Reds (Carl Mays, Wally Pipp, Everett Scott) and 1931 Tigers (Joe Dugan, Waite Hoyt, Wally Schang) had three each.

Accomplishments

Sam Jones, no-hitter on September 4
Babe Ruth, AL MVP

Season Summary

When you think of this era's Yankees you probably think of a dominating offense led by the home run ball Babe Ruth pioneered. Well...you'd be close. The Yanks led the AL in homers, but their offense wasn't very deep after Ruth. So great was the Babe though, that the Yankees finished second in runs scored and third in OPS+. Their run prevention was the real key to their success. Their team ERA+, strikeout-to-walk ratio and defensive efficiency were all league tops. Frustrated after two straight World Series defeats, the Yankees bolstered their rotation by acquiring Herb Pennock from the Red Sox. Pennock would go 19-6 with a 126 ERA+ (both good for second on the team) and win two World Series games, including the clinching Game 6. He was a strong addition to an already-strong staff that included Joe Bush, Waite Hoyt, Sam Jones and Bob Shawkey.

The season began with the opening of the legendary "House That Ruth Built," AKA Yankee Stadium. No longer would the Yankees have to share the Polo Grounds with the Giants. Fittingly, Ruth hit the ballpark's first home run in the third inning on Opening Day. Another noteworthy change came in May, when co-owner Jacob Ruppert bought out his partner Tillinghast L'Hommedieu Huston to gain complete control of the franchise. The pennant race was nothing worth mentioning, as the Yankees were never out of first after May 4 and won the league by 16 games.

For the third year in a row the Yankees' National League opponent in October was the Giants. It looked like the same old story when the Giants led the Series 2-1 after three games, but the Yankees stormed back with decisive wins in the next two matches. Game 6 was won when the Yanks used a five-run eighth to come from behind. Incredibly, Babe Ruth struck out in his only at-bat during the rally. It was Bob Meusel's two-run single (plus a third run that scored on a throwing error) that gave the pinstripers their final and Series-clinching lead.

Thursday, October 29, 2009

PTWSW #19: The 1922 New York Giants

Manager: John McGraw
Record: 93-61
Ballpark: Polo Grounds
Owners: Francis X. McQuade and Charles Stoneham
Coaches: Jesse Burkett, Cozy Dolan, Hughie Jennings

Future Hall of Famers: Dave Bancroft, Frankie Frisch, Travis Jackson, George Kelly, Casey Stengel, Ross Youngs

Team Leaders, Batting

BA:
Frank Snyder, .343
OBP: Ross Youngs, .398
SLG: Irish Meusel, .509
OPS: Irish Meusel, .877
HR: Georke Kelly, 17
RBI: Irish Meusel, 132
SB: Frankie Frisch, 31

Team Leaders, Pitching

W:
Art Nehf, 19
SO: Rosy Ryan, 75
ERA: Phil Douglas, 2.63
IP: Art Nehf, 268.1

Tidbits

Oldest Player: Fred Toney (b. December 11, 1888)

Youngest Player: Travis Jackson (b. November 2, 1903)

First to Leave Us: Ross Youngs (d. October 22, 1927)

Last Survivor: Carmen Hill (d. January 1, 1990)

First in Majors: Technically it was Cozy Dolan, who debuted on August 15, 1909, but he was a coach who only got into one game. Among regular players, it was Fred Toney, whose debut was on April 15, 1911.

Last in Majors: Fred Johnson (final game May 10, 1939). Johnson actually spent 1924 through 1937 in the minors before resurfacing with the Browns for two years.

First to Play For the Franchise: Heinie Groh (April 12, 1912)

Last to Play For the Franchise: Travis Jackson (September 24, 1936)

Pre-union Team: The 1919 Braves (Red Causey, Art Nehf, Johnny Rawlings, Hugh McQuillan and Jack Scott) and 1920 Phillies (Dave Bancroft, Red Causey, Irish Meusel, Johnny Rawlings and Casey Stengel) each had five.

Reunion Team: The 1924 Braves with five (Dave Bancroft, Jesse Barnes, Bill Cunningham, Earl Smith and Casey Stengel). Also noteworthy are the pennant-winning 1927 Pirates with four (Mike Cvengros, Heinie Groh, Carmen Hill and Earl Smith).

Accomplishments

Ross Youngs, cycle on April 29

Season Summary

The Giants' offense led the league in only one major category (though it didn't exist at the time): on-base percentage. They were second- or third-best everywhere else. Their defensive efficiency and fielding percentage were both tops in the Senior Circuit, and those first-rate glovemen helped the pitching staff allow the fewest runs and post a league-best 116 ERA+.

The pennant race wasn't a come-from-behind story like the previous year's. The Giants spent almost the entire season in first place, with only the Cardinals pulling ahead of them at any point after the first few weeks. The most exciting period of the season was between July 14 and August 16, when neither team had more than a 2.5-game lead.

Perhaps the most noteworthy event that season was the scandal involving pitcher "Shufflin' Phil" Douglas. Douglas was a talented but problematic player who often butted heads with John McGraw. In July he wrote a letter to Cardinals outfielder Les Mann offering to quit the Giants in exchange for money, thereby leaving his detested manager shorthanded in the pennant race. Instead of dealing with Douglas, Mann sent the letter to McGraw. When confronted with the evidence, Douglas confessed his guilt and was subsequently banned from baseball. It was the most shocking incident to hit the American Pastime since the "Black Sox" were exposed two years earlier.

The loss of Douglas didn't hurt the Giants as much as the pitcher thought it would. McGraw's men won the pennant by seven games and got a rematch with the Yankees in the World Series. The Yankees won three Series games the previous year, but this time they wouldn't manage to win even one. The closest they'd come would be a tie when Game 2 was called on account of darkness. The Giants got two of their wins on 8th-inning comebacks, including the clinching Game 5. George Kelly's two-run single scored the tying and go-ahead runs, and the Yankees went quietly in the 9th to give the Giants back-to-back titles.