|1st||Jake Peavy||Gene Tenace||Adrian Gonzalez||Roberto Alomar||Ken Caminiti||Ozzie Smith||Gene Richards||Kevin McReynolds||Tony Gwynn|
|2nd||Andy Ashby||Terry Kennedy||Nate Colbert||Mark Loretta||Phil Nevin||Khalil Greene||Carmelo Martinez||Darrin Jackson||Dave Winfield|
|3rd||Andy Benes||Benito Santiago||Ryan Klesko||Tim Flannery||Chase Headley||Garry Templeton||Greg Vaughn||Mark Kotsay||Brian Giles|
|4th||Ed Whitson||Nick Hundley||Fred McGriff||Quilvio Veras||Sean Burroughs||Everth Cabrera||Carlos Quentin||Cameron Maybin||Ollie Brown|
Interesting results. The middle infield of their 1st Team has two guys that were associated with other franchises. Alomar and Smith were good enough in short periods of time to earn the top spots.
Some of these required a lot of debate over longevity vs. peak. The Padres are a decidedly non-storied franchise, so many of these guys didn't have long tenures in San Diego. Ed Whitson got the nod over franchise icon Randy Jones just because of his two great years at the end of his career, which topped Jones' short peak. But I might've given it to Jones on a different day. At the keystone, Mark Loretta had an argument for the top spot, but Alomar had three years of star-level play, which bettered Loretta's two, despite Loretta's good years being better than Alomar's. It's all subjective.
In left field, it's safe to say these guys ain't the Red Sox. Gene Richards was an easy choice for the top spot, despite being rather obscure today. At the other side of the outfield though, the Padres have probably their deepest position: Their all-time greatest player, followed by a Hall of Famer, followed by a guy who had an extremely underrated career, followed by an early star.
I predicted Steve Finley would take the top spot in center field, but he ended up not making the list at all, since WAR didn't think very highly of his defense. I never even thought about the possibility of Darrin Jackson making the 2nd Team, but WAR loved his defense that much.
The hot corner has been a pretty good position for the Friars. Their top four players all manned the position from the 1990s onward. Graig Nettles came close, but Burroughs barely beat him out. If only the Padres had someone good there now...
First base and catcher were also surprisingly strong positions. Hats off to the Padres. They're an oft-overlooked team, but their talent acquisition has been pretty good over the years.