P | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st | David Price | Toby Hall | Carlos Pena | Ben Zobrist | Evan Longoria | Julio Lugo | Carl Crawford | Melvin Upton | Matt Joyce |
2nd | James Shields | Dioner Navarro | Fred McGriff | Logan Forsythe | Aubrey Huff | Jason Bartlett | Desmond Jennings | Rocco Baldelli | Ben Grieve |
3rd | Scott Kazmir | John Flaherty | Travis Lee | Miguel Cairo | Jared Sandberg | Kevin Stocker | Greg Vaughn | Randy Winn | Dave Martinez |
So...that 3rd Team is brutal. What do you expect from a franchise with such a short and usually bad history? Center field was fairly strong though, and once Kevin Kiermaier gets another year under his belt, he'll probably at least make it to the 2nd Team. Catcher was definitely the weakest position here. No offense to Toby Hall, but he wouldn't even crack the 6th Team for some franchises.
I'm hoping to recompile these in perhaps about five years, if I'm still doing this blog then. Certainly some players will have moved up or down on the lists, and even some players yet to debut will probably be there for a few of them. For now though, enjoy the 2015-16 rankings in all their up-to-date comprehensiveness.