P | C | 1B | 2B | 3B | SS | LF | CF | RF | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1st | Kenny Rogers | Ivan Rodriguez | Rafael Palmeiro | Ian Kinsler | Buddy Bell | Alex Rodriguez | Frank Howard | Oddibe McDowell | Juan Gonzalez |
2nd | Charlie Hough | Jim Sundberg | Mark Teixeira | Julio Franco | Adrian Beltre | Elvis Andrus | Rusty Greer | Don Lock | Ruben Sierra |
3rd | Fergie Jenkins | Paul Casanova | Will Clark | Bump Wills | Ken McMullen | Toby Harrah | Josh Hamilton | Leonys Martin | Nelson Cruz |
4th | Nolan Ryan | Gerald Laird | Pete O'Brien | Mark McLemore | Hank Blalock | Scott Fletcher | Billy Sample | Mickey Rivers | Jeff Burroughs |
I hated to put Josh Hamilton on the 3rd Team, but I didn't feel right about putting him in center field, and he only had that one big MVP season while playing primarily left. The truth is though, Hamilton probably isn't (or wasn't) as great as that season, all things considered, so maybe it's perfectly fitting not to rank him very high.
Michael Young played too many positions to put him at any one, and since the Rangers are pretty strong at shortstop, Young's most logical position, he was off the board completely. Ed Brinkman was another fine player at that position who didn't make the cut. It's a shame there wasn't a place for Mr. Ranger somewhere.
I was surprised at how strong third base, pitcher, and right field were. Center field was weak, and catcher was extremely top-heavy. Jim Sundberg was probably good enough to be some teams' #1, but here he's stuck behind Pudge. After those two, the cupboard is pretty bare.